Choosing To Carry Arthur

I know this is a touchy subject and the topic of abortion is a very emotional one. My intention is not to bring judgement on those who have chosen differently. There is deep hurt in all women who have faced this decision whether they choose to terminate a pregnancy or continue carrying a baby with a poor or fatal diagnosis. But I feel like I must speak out on our situation, because we are in a minority and people need to know of the option we have chosen. Although the road we are walking is a painful one, it is beautiful and has the potential to bring much joy and lasting impact – I am speaking from my own experience thus far, and seeing the beauty, depth and character in the lives of others who have already walked this journey and similar ones. Upon finding out the diagnosis of anencephaly for their child, 95% of couples choose to terminate the pregnancy. So when I say I feel in the minority, I really feel it. Artie and I are in the 5%. This post is for those who would ever find themselves in the position we are in, to give you a reason to choose life even in the face of death.

Artie and I sat in the ultrasound room stunned by the words, “Something is very wrong. Your baby has a heartbeat. But your baby will not be compatible with life outside the womb. I am so sorry.” A few things that followed felt odd to me. The doctor then started giving us information and statistics about future pregnancies, and my mind couldn’t process it. It was as if this one was already over. I kept asking her to clarify that she was talking about things far in the future, future pregnancies and children, while my mind was stuck presently in this horrible moment, deeply concerned for my child still living in my body. Then she began to talk about our options from this point. It caught me a little off guard that terminating the pregnancy was the first thing offered.** The thought hadn’t even come to my mind. I remember not even consulting with Artie before telling the doc we would continue this pregnancy for however long we would get with him. It didn’t need to be brought up again. My love for this child began well before that scan, and it wouldn’t cease now. In fact, it intensified and deepened in those minutes after. For me it wasn’t even a choice. His life mattered more than whatever dreams I had for our family.

Let me share with you why it wasn’t even a decision for us, even in one of the most emotionally vulnerable times of our lives. It all comes from who God is:

God is the Creator – of this world and of all life. He is in control and nothing is hidden from His sight, even in the days we didn’t know we were pregnant, God knew and was doing work.

“When I look at your heavens, the work of your fingers, the moon and the stars, which you have set in place, what is man that you are mindful of him, and the son of man that you care for him? Yet you have made him a little lower than the heavenly beings and crowned him with glory and honor.” Psalm 8:3-5

“For you formed my inward parts; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Wonderful are your works, my soul knows it very well. My frame was not hidden from you, when I was being made in secret, intricately woven in the depth of the earth. Your eyes saw my unformed substance; in your book were written, every one of them, the days that were formed for me, when as yet there was none of them.” Psalm 139:13-16

“Know that the Lord, He is God! It is he who made us and we are his; we are his people, the sheep of his pasture.” Psalm 100:3

Oh how I love these verses, especially now! Not only does it give me confidence that God knows me and loves me, but that He knows and loves Arthur so much more intimately than I ever could. Each and every person ever created has dignity and worth. The diagnosis of anencephaly has a range of outcomes: some only know life inside the womb, some pass during delivery, some live a few minutes after birth, some a few hours, some a few days, and in the rare cases months. I do not know the number of Arthur’s days. It’s not up to me to determine them. God already knows and it’s not a surprise to Him. It’s perfectly planned. Why is Arthur’s life valuable and worth continuing? His value doesn’t come from his health, but from the fact he was created by God.

God works in mysterious and miraculous ways – check this story out:

“As [Jesus] passed by, he saw a man blind from birth. And his disciples asked him, ‘Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?’ Jesus answered, ‘It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be displayed in him.'” John 9:1-3 

Keep reading through the rest of the chapter, it’s too long to put on here. Jesus goes on to give this man the ability to see, something he had been missing his whole life. He performed a miracle and this man’s life was a testimony to others of who Jesus was. I have thought of this passage often. Why is Arthur missing part of his skull and brain? Is it because I did something wrong? Is it something he deserves? No. It is that the works of God might be displayed in and through his precious and valuable life. What would the parents of this man have done if they had the technology of ultrasounds and testing for abnormalities? Many people these days, in their situation would choose to end the pregnancy either because the quality of life for their child wouldn’t be what they would have hoped for, or the burden of dealing with his deficiency might be too much for them to bear. What if they had and they had missed this opportunity for a miracle to happen in his life? What about Arthur? Maybe he will be miraculously healed. Maybe God will do something different. I don’t know, it’s not up to me to determine. But God is going to do a work through his life one way or another, and I can’t wait to see it. That is another reason I choose to carry Arthur.

God gave himself –

“but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us.” Romans 5:8 

Currently living in the midst of this situation, I can see how people would choose to end their pregnancy and have dealt with some of those emotions myself. Why delay the inevitable? You can start the grieving process and move on to try again for another child sooner. Who wants to go through the third trimester discomforts when there’s possibly no baby to take home at the end of it? Understandable feelings, but to act on those feelings is opposite of the gospel, the “good news” of what Jesus did. It’s, “You die so that I can live more fully”. That’s not love – it’s love of self. Jesus says “I’ll die so that you can live more fully”. Jesus shows his love by giving up Himself for us. I wrote in another post about Jesus wrestling with his emotions (here), but He ultimately chose love.  If I am to be a follower of Christ, I need to do things His way, following His example. “If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself, take up his cross daily and follow me.” Luke 9:23. I am choosing to carry Arthur and love him sacrificially, to die to parts of myself in a sense, because Jesus chose to carry the cross and die for me.

As you can tell, this decision is not just a personal one, but a deeply theological one. These children’s lives matter and are worth being celebrated, just as your’s matters. Arthur is our son whether we only hold him for a short time or whether we get to watch him grow up. I pray and hope that more would choose to not end these pregnancies, not just to have more people on our team, but because I desire more for people (particularly the parents) to experience love in a deeper measure and for these children to experience that love, being valued for their existence, not just their contribution to the family.


This little hat was made especially for Arthur, by a woman who makes crocheted hats specifically for babies with anencephaly, and free of charge to the families that receive them. What a wonderful gift. If you would like to contribute to Lisa Borders’ ministry or receive some yourself for your child, please visit her Facebook Page, Anencephaly Hope.

I am more than happy to talk with you if you have questions or even a differing view point. Please send me a private message or an email, and I will try to get back to you when I can.



**I will clarify that I have had a great experience with our healthcare team – our nurse midwives and OBs, the high-risk doctor, and the perinatal specialists and palliative care team. They have been wonderful to us given such a terrible circumstance. We were never pressured into having an abortion, it was just the first option given to us.


9 thoughts on “Choosing To Carry Arthur

  1. Teresa Sharp says:

    Thanks for choosing to be baby Arthur’s tent…”For we know that when this tent he lives in-his body here on earth-is torn down, God will have a house in heaven for him to live in, a home he himself has made which will last for ever.” 2 Cor 5:1. As you continue reading the chapter you see how we long to be transformed. Thank you for choosing faith, what is unseen rather than sight…may the Holy Spirit continue to fill you with courage as you savor every moment with His precious creation. Love, Teresa


  2. Melony Walker says:

    I am praying for your family and your sweet baby boy. Although we have never met I am friends with your sister and I am keeping up with your blog. I hope that faith and love from your friends and family can sustain you through the days to come.


  3. I randomly stumbled across your blog when a friend of mine liked it on Facebook. So glad that I did.
    I just gave birth to my son last month, after doctors gave us less-than-hopeful news of his chances of survival. I will say that I do not regret it one bit. Enjoy every moment that you have. God will give you strength when you least expect it and will use your story. Hugs!


  4. Terri Knight says:

    This is so well-spoken, Kittery, because it is filled with truth. God’s grace is made evident through your testimony. May this message of Christ and His gospel be spread far and near. We are praying for your family and this precious little one.


  5. Rebecca says:

    God bless you and thank you so much for sharing your story. As a mother of three, I cannot imagine having to go through what you are now. I’m sure it was very difficult to come public with this, but hopefully it will help someone else who is going through something similar. We all have our own walk to go through in life, but the beautiful thing is that God is always there to comfort those in need. As a Christian, a mom, and a NICU nurse, abortion is something I feel very strongly against. I have seen so many situations where babies that shouldn’t have survived did and babies that should have did not. It is in God’s hands and not for us to decide. Thank you for your bravery, your compassion, and your testimony. I will be praying for your whole family.


  6. Dotsie says:

    So well said, Kittery. A clear testimony of God’s power and grace in your life. Choosing life for Arthur is already a big Glory to God, our heavenly Father, who does ALL things well.


  7. haarhoffs says:

    Thank you so much for sharing your story… and for loving your sweet boy, even though he has some serious medical challenges. May this blog post be an inspiration to others to love their sick or handicapped children in the womb, as you have done.

    One thing I would add to your post is that it is important for us to judge abortion rightly. John 7:24 says, “Do not judge by appearances, but judge with right judgment.” We can feel confident that we are judging rightly when we are judging according to the Word of God. A good starting point is the 6th commandment that says, “Thou shall not murder.” There are no exclusions given in that commandment for handicapped/sick children, human beings up a few inches in the womb, size of the person, age of the person, etc. It’s just simply, “Thou shall not murder.” I do believe it’s not only okay, but actually RIGHT… to speak of the sin of abortion as 100% evil.

    When we align our thoughts with God’s thoughts on this issue, it helps to clarify so much, doesn’t it….

    While we can’t judge a person unto eternal life or death — that judgment belongs to God alone –, we can certainly recognize that those who commit the sin of murder of their little ones will stand before God someday and answer to Him, according to their deeds. I certainly don’t want that to happen to anyone who does not know Christ! That’s why I believe the Gospel should be the response to every abortion-bound woman. It is evil and we must declare it as evil — not join the world in declaring it a “personal decision” or “option.” But gently showing abortion-minded sinners how abortion violates God’s law and how they must repent and turn to Christ.

    I actually work daily via counseling aborting mothers. Not at a Pregnancy Help Center where they are talking about what to maybe do, but rather with the ones who are actually doing it — the ones with appointments to kill their defenseless infants.

    I never could have imagined before stepping out to counsel these women from the Word how much sin — and not just deep hurt — is at the root of their decision to abort… and even in their thinking post-abortive. While two mothers that I’ve talked to this week have chosen life and cancelled their abortion appointments, one did not. Just to give you a “face,” so to speak of the one who chose to go through with it, let me tell you WHY she was aborting: her husband cheated on her and she was seeking revenge. She intentionally waited until their baby girl was 19 weeks old to pay to dismember her baby while alive — just because she knew the later age would be like a “dagger in his heart.” She knew the baby would suffer more… and she did it anyway to get back at her husband who wanted that daughter with all his heart.

    These are the stories of the mothers I counsel. It is usually a selfish, selfish thing to abort one’s child. These days, the aborting mothers don’t even argue that it’s not a baby. They speak of the “baby” and even use words like “killing” or “murder.” One of my last mothers this past week — one who chose life, thankfully — wrote me and said, “I’m just not sure if I can go through with killing the baby.” That was her terminology — not mine. Women are not ignorant as to the humanity of their unborn these days.

    These mothers, by and large, today are not “victims.” They are knowingly and willingly participating in the premeditated murder of their little ones. I’ve even had some mothers come out post-abortive at the clinics yelling “VICTORY!!!!” and holding up a “V” sign. Others have come out dancing (from the waist up) in celebration of what they had done.There is very little remorse with most of them, unless God changes their hearts.

    I know we want to be gentle in our approach to these mothers, but I would make a suggestion to not join in the world’s terminology via words like “termination” — which the world uses to sort of sugar-coat or hide the abortion process.Let’s use Biblical language. When we use the word “murder,” it makes it so easy to refer back to the 6th commandment… which then shows their need for a Savior (perfect opportunity for the Gospel!).

    My random thoughts for what they’re worth. Cheering you on in your defense of the unborn!… while simultaneously grieving with you over the health challenges your baby boy is facing. I’m so thankful that you see your baby boy as the precious Psalm 127 gift that he is — no matter how long his days on this earth.

    Thank you so much for sharing your story. ❤


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s